Extra Butter hats & caps, cheapest first
155 hats & caps in stock at Extra Butter. Cheapest right now: $22.50; typical price $55. Extra Butter marks 14% of them "on sale"; the badges say which of those sales are real.
-
Thisisneverthat Times Cap
Extra Butter
$22.50 Real deal
Quality: Good
-
Carhartt WIP Mens Commuting Tales Beanie
Extra Butter · 2 stores
$27.50 Real deal
Quality: Good
-
Dime Waxed Worker Cap
Extra Butter
$28 Not really a sale
Quality: Good
-
Adidas World Cup USA 94 Fan Cap
Extra Butter
$28 Not really a sale
Quality: Good
-
Adidas FIFA World Cup 26™ US94 Cap
Extra Butter
$28 Not really a sale
Quality: Good
-
Nike Dri-Fit Club Metal Logo Cap
Extra Butter
$28
Quality: Good
-
Thisisneverthat Original Gear Denim Cap
Extra Butter
$30 Real deal
Quality: Good
-
Chadie Dek Snapback Hat
Extra Butter
$30 Real deal
Quality: Good
-
Extra Butter Official Selection Knit Beanie
Extra Butter
$30
Quality: Good
-
Extra Butter Official Selection Knit Beanie
Extra Butter
$30
Quality: Good
-
Extra Butter McCallister Knit Beanie
Extra Butter
$30
Quality: Good
-
San San Gear Mens Logo Beanie
Extra Butter
$31 Real deal
Quality: Good
-
Nike Apex Faux Fur Bucket Hat
Extra Butter
$31.50 Not really a sale
Quality: Good
-
Amomento Fur Bucket Hat
Extra Butter
$33.80 Real deal
Quality: Good
-
Extra Butter x '47 Graphic Trucker FM Hat
Extra Butter
$37
Quality: Good
-
Extra Butter x '47 Thorton Hitch Trucker Hat
Extra Butter
$37
Quality: Good
-
Extra Butter x '47 "Soundclash" Captain Hat
Extra Butter
$37
Quality: Good
-
Extra Butter x '47 EBNY Bowery Hitch Snapback Hat
Extra Butter
$37
Quality: Good
-
Extra Butter x '47 EBNY Bowery Hitch Snapback Hat
Extra Butter
$37
Quality: Good
-
Extra Butter x '47 Cotton Wreath Hitch Hat
Extra Butter
$37
Quality: Good
-
Extra Butter x '47 "Soundclash" Pinwheel Captain Hat
Extra Butter
$37
Quality: Good
-
Extra Butter x '47 Cotton Wreath Hitch Hat
Extra Butter
$37
Quality: Good
-
Extra Butter x '47 Official Selection Hitch Snapback Hat
Extra Butter
$37
Quality: Good
-
Dime Glo Dime Low Pro Cap
Extra Butter
$39
Quality: Good
-
Dime Cursive Denim Worker Cap
Extra Butter
$39
Quality: Good
-
Dime Classic Houndstooth Low Pro Cap
Extra Butter
$40
Quality: Good
-
Mitchell & Ness x New York Knicks NBA Champions Script Dad Hat
Extra Butter
$40
Quality: Good
-
Adidas x Extra Butter Chubbs Bucket Hat
Extra Butter
$40
Quality: Good
-
Dime Cursive D Worker Cap
Extra Butter
$40
Quality: Good
-
Adidas Mens SP5DER Cap
Extra Butter
$42 Real deal
Quality: Good
-
New Era 9Fifty Curved New York Yankee World Series 00 Hat
Extra Butter
$42
Quality: Good
-
New Era 9Fifty Curved New York Mets ASG64 Hat
Extra Butter
$42
Quality: Good
-
New Era 9Fifty Curved Los Angeles Dodger 60 Years Hat
Extra Butter
$42
Quality: Good
-
New Era 9Fifty Curved New York Yankee 100th Hat
Extra Butter
$42
Quality: Good
-
New Era 9Fifty Curved Los Angeles Dodger World Series 24 Hat
Extra Butter
$42
Quality: Good
-
New Era 9Fifty Curved New York Mets 86 World Series Hat
Extra Butter
$42
Quality: Good
-
New Era 950AF Curve New York Knicks 2026 Champions Snapback Hat
Extra Butter
$45
Quality: Good
-
New Era 950 New York Knicks 2026 Champions Snapback Hat
Extra Butter
$45
Quality: Good
-
New Era 59Fifty New York Knicks 2026 Champions Fitted Hat
Extra Butter
$45
Quality: Good
-
New Era 950AF Curve New York Knicks 2026 Champions Snapback Hat
Extra Butter
$45
Quality: Good
-
New Era 950 New York Knicks 2026 Champions Snapback Hat
Extra Butter
$45
Quality: Good
-
Thisisneverthat SP-Logo No Cuff Beanie
Extra Butter
$45
Quality: Good
-
Thisisneverthat Times Cap
Extra Butter
$45
Quality: Good
-
47 New York Yankees Coop World Series Clean Up Hat
Extra Butter
$45
Quality: Good
-
47 New York Mets Coop World Series Pinstripe MVP Hat
Extra Butter
$45
Quality: Good
-
47 New York Mets Coop World Series Painters Cap
Extra Butter
$45
Quality: Good
-
Bandit Running Waffle Beanie
Extra Butter
$45
Quality: Good
-
Extra Butter x 47 Gallagher Bucket Hat
Extra Butter
$45
Quality: Good
Narrow these down by size, color or price · Girls' hats & caps · Boys' hats & caps